At a glance: When to lease vs buy
- Choose lease when cash flow matters more than ownership, you upgrade often, or you prefer predictable repayments and an end-of-term return/upgrade path.
- Choose buy (e.g., chattel mortgage or hire purchase) when you want ownership, plan to keep the asset long-term, and want potential GST and depreciation benefits.
- Short asset life or fast tech change? Lean towards operating/finance lease with a residual and easy upgrade options.
- Long asset life or high resale value? Buying can reduce lifetime cost once finance is repaid.
Hire or buy an excavator for one contract?
A common version of this question: you have won a large job, the machine has to be on site before the first progress claim is paid, and you are weighing dry hire by the day or week against financing an excavator you may not keep busy once the contract ends. The sum most people are trying to do is simple.
The break-even sum
- Hire cost: weekly dry hire rate x weeks on site (add transport each way, and check whether the hire rate assumes a 40 hour week or charges extra hours).
- Finance cost over the same months: monthly repayment x months on site, plus insurance, servicing and transport, minus what you can realistically sell the machine for at the end after paying out the loan.
- Rule of thumb: if the machine will work fewer than roughly 150 days a year, hiring usually comes out ahead. Above that, owning usually wins. One contract alone rarely gets a machine to that level, so the honest question is what happens after this job.
Worked example (illustrative only, your quotes will differ):
- Contract: 12 months, machine needed around four days a week, roughly 45 weeks on site.
- Dry hire at $1,200 a week x 45 weeks = $54,000, plus transport. That money is gone at the end.
- Finance on a used machine at $90,000 over four years with a 30% balloon might land somewhere around $1,900 a month depending on rate and term. 12 months = about $22,800 in repayments, plus insurance and servicing you now carry.
- The catch: after 12 months you still owe most of the price. If you sell the machine, the loan payout comes off the sale price. If you keep it working on the next job, the comparison swings firmly to owning. If it sits in the yard, you are paying for a machine that earns nothing.
What the sum leaves out
- Resale value: the real finance cost is repayments plus running costs minus what you sell it for, not just the repayments. Hire money has no resale.
- Owner's costs: maintenance, insurance, transport, attachments and downtime all fall on you. On hire, a breakdown is the hire company's problem and the machine gets swapped.
- Work after the job: be honest about whether you have the next contract, or whether you can wet or dry hire the machine out between jobs.
- Tax: hire is a straight deduction. Owning gives depreciation, interest deductions and an upfront GST claim on a chattel mortgage if you are registered. Confirm with your accountant.
Cash flow before the first progress claim
The reason this search happens is timing: the first invoice is weeks away and the machine is needed now. If the numbers favour owning, ask a broker about structures built for exactly this:
- No deposit finance so the purchase does not drain the cash you need for wages and materials in month one.
- Deferred first repayment, where some lenders allow the first instalment to start a month or more after settlement.
- Structured or seasonal repayments that sit lower in the early months and step up once progress claims are flowing.
- A shorter term with a larger balloon that keeps the monthly figure close to the weekly hire rate, with the balloon set near expected resale so you can sell or refinance at the end of the contract.
- Rent to own or hire with a purchase option as a middle path: you hire for the contract and some of the hire paid counts towards the purchase if you decide to keep the machine. Read the terms, because the credited portion and the buyout price vary.
Lenders will want to see the signed contract or purchase order as evidence the machine has income behind it. That matters most if your ABN is under two years old or your last financials do not yet reflect this size of job. Lower-hour used machines are usually easier to finance than very old gear.
The quickest way to settle it: send the contract value and length, the machine quote and your hire quote through the form, and a broker can come back with a repayment figure and structure you can set directly beside the weekly hire rate.
Get a repayment figure to compare with my hire quote Excavator finance explained No deposit asset finance
How the options work in Australia
“Lease vs buy” usually means comparing four common structures used for business equipment:
- Chattel Mortgage (buy): You own the asset from settlement. Repayments cover principal and interest. Optional balloon to reduce monthly cost. Typically allows upfront GST claim on the purchase price (if registered).
- Hire Purchase (buy at end): Lender buys the asset and you gain ownership after the final payment. Cash flow can look similar to a chattel mortgage.
- Finance Lease (lease): You rent the asset with a set residual due at the end. Often used when you want lower payments and potential end-of-term options.
- Operating Lease (lease/rent): Pay to use the asset, then return or upgrade at term end. Often includes servicing options and keeps things simple for frequent upgrades.
Chattel mortgage explained Finance lease options Operating lease options Hire purchase explained
Cost comparison: repayments, total cost and tax
The real comparison is total cost of ownership (TCO) vs total cost of use. A simple way to frame it:
- Buying (chattel/hire purchase): Upfront GST claim on purchase (if registered), interest is deductible, and you claim depreciation. A balloon reduces repayments but increases interest and the amount due at term end.
- Leasing (finance/operating): Repayments are generally deductible to the extent of business use. GST is paid on each lease payment and claimed over time. Residual affects monthly cost and end-of-term outcome.
Worked example (illustrative only):
- Equipment price (ex-GST): $80,000
- Term: 5 years
- Comparison 1 - Chattel Mortgage with 20% balloon: typically lower lifetime cost if you keep the asset beyond year 5 and the balloon is paid or refinanced cheaply.
- Comparison 2 - Finance Lease with 20% residual: typically lower monthly repayments than a no-balloon buy, easier upgrade/return path at term end.
Tax rules change and outcomes vary by structure and usage. Always confirm with your accountant before proceeding.
GST and tax treatment in brief
- Chattel Mortgage / Hire Purchase: GST on the purchase price is usually claimable upfront if you are registered for GST. Interest and many fees are GST-free. Deduct interest and claim depreciation per ATO rules.
- Finance / Operating Lease: GST is charged on each payment and claimed progressively. Lease payments are typically deductible to the extent of business use. A residual may apply at the end of a finance lease.
- Accounting: Standards such as AASB-16 may affect balance sheet treatment. Seek accounting advice for your specific situation.
Ownership, residuals and balloons
- Ownership now: Chattel mortgage provides ownership from day one.
- Ownership at end: Hire purchase transfers ownership after the final payment.
- No ownership by default: Finance/operating leases leave ownership with the lessor; you may pay a residual to keep it or return/upgrade.
- Residual/Balloon level: Higher residuals/balloons lower monthly cost but increase the amount due at term end. Set these to match expected resale value and upgrade plans.
Pros and cons summary
Leasing advantages
- Lower monthly payments vs no-balloon loans
- Easier upgrades and predictable end-of-term options
- GST claimed on each payment (no large upfront GST outlay)
Leasing drawbacks
- No ownership unless you pay the residual
- Total cost can be higher if you would otherwise keep the asset long-term
Buying advantages
- Ownership benefits and potential long-term cost savings
- Upfront GST claim on purchase (if registered)
- Flexibility with balloons to shape repayments
Buying drawbacks
- More capital tied up if no balloon or low balloon
- Harder to upgrade mid-term without selling/refinancing
Match structure to your asset and upgrade cycle
- Fast-moving tech (IT, office electronics, POS): Operate or finance lease with shorter terms and planned upgrades.
- Vehicles and yellow goods (utes, vans, excavators): Either approach can work. If you cycle fleets often, leasing can help; if you keep long-term, buying can win on total cost.
- Long-life plant and machinery: Buying may be more efficient if you’ll use it beyond the finance term.
- Specialised medical/dental/fitness equipment: Consider leasing for upgrades and service packages; consider buying for core, durable assets you’ll keep.
Explore equipment finance Ask which structure fits your upgrade cycle
Approval and documentation: what lenders look for
- Business profile: ABN/ACN, time trading, industry, and how the asset generates income.
- Financials: Bank statements, BAS, financial statements, or low-doc alternatives depending on lender and amount.
- Asset details: Supplier quote/contract, age and condition, serial/VIN where applicable.
- Fit for purpose: Clear story on why the chosen structure (lease or buy) suits cash flow, ownership goals, and upgrade plans.
Get help comparing hire, lease or buy for your equipment
Tell us what you need and we'll match you with a broker and email you their introduction. Reply to it and they'll contact you directly. Free, no obligation.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to lease or buy equipment in Australia?
It depends on how long you’ll keep the asset, your tax position, interest rates, and residual/balloon settings. Leasing may lower monthly payments and suit upgrades; buying can lower lifetime cost if you keep the asset beyond the term.
Is it cheaper to hire or buy an excavator for one contract?
For a single contract with nothing lined up afterwards, dry hire is usually cheaper and carries no resale risk. Financing wins once the machine will work well over 100 to 150 days a year or you can keep it busy after the job, because repayments buy an asset you can sell or keep working while hire money is gone. Compare the weekly hire rate x weeks on site against monthly repayments x months, less realistic resale, and factor in insurance, servicing and transport. A no deposit, deferred first repayment or larger balloon structure can bridge the gap until the first progress claim is paid.
How does GST work for lease vs buy?
Leases generally charge GST on each payment (claimed over time). Buying via chattel mortgage or hire purchase usually lets you claim GST on the purchase upfront if you’re registered. Confirm details with your accountant.
Which option gives me ownership?
Chattel mortgage gives ownership from day one. Hire purchase transfers it at the end. Finance or operating leases don’t give ownership unless you pay a residual and elect to keep the asset.
What term lengths and residuals are common?
3-5 years is typical for many assets. Residuals/balloons commonly range 10-40% depending on asset life, usage and lender policy. The right setting balances monthly affordability with your expected end-of-term plan.
Can startups or low-doc applicants get approved?
Yes. Some lenders offer low-doc, startup and self-employed options, often with additional conditions such as stronger asset classes, higher residuals, or director guarantees.
Final takeaway
Leasing vs buying equipment in Australia comes down to how you balance cash flow, ownership, tax/GST, and upgrade needs. If you’ll upgrade often and value lower repayments, a lease can fit. If you’ll keep the asset long-term, buying can win on total cost.
If you’re unsure, request a side-by-side comparison based on your asset, term, and business use.